Logopedia:Montages/Nominations

If you've found or written and article which you think deserves Good Article status, you may nominate it here.

Please note that a Good Article should meet the criterias listed on Logopedia:Good articles.

To nominate an article, please click HERE, copy the following template. Remember to fill out all the fields.

==NAME OF ARTICLE== *Nominated by: ~ *Motivation: Please motivate why you think the article deserves Good Article status here.

Discussion

NBC

 * Nominated by: Izzyfan :) Is that.... a HOBO?Oh No its not its just Ezekiel... OR IS IT? o.O 19:23, August 30, 2010 (UTC)
 * Motivation: Please motivate why you think the article deserves Good Article status here. Cause it has videos that shows the ID's had Many info on most logos!

Discussion

Decline. I think the article needs much more work put into it. I'll list some of it: In conclusion, I can come up with much more things that should be said about the rich history of this television network's identity. Väsk 08:41, August 31, 2010 (UTC)
 * It generally lacks a certain "completeness" which I think Good articles should have. There's lots of loose ends to tie up.
 * It doesn't have any sources.
 * The sections for 1962, 1976 and 1979 don't have any text in them.
 * There are dozens of typos.
 * There's unclear statements, such as "This logo was never alone".
 * There's lots more to write about how and when the logo was used. We ought to include some descriptions of the on-screen presentation for the last decade.
 * The situation about how the snake logo and the Laramie pacock were used together needs to be cleared up.
 * I'm fairly certain that the logo which the article claims was used between 1962-1975 is false.

Nine Network

 * Nominated by: Webj444 December 14, 2010 (UTC)
 * Motivation: Nine Network has many Logo & lots of Info on every logo.

Discussion

Decline I disagree, it has hardly any info on the logos, and it is quite confusing. Needs research and some sorting out before it can be considered. Väsk 12:43, December 16, 2010 (UTC)

Channel 4

 * Nominated by:-- Webj444 07:34, December 16, 2010 (UTC)
 * Motivation: Channel 4 has lots of logo Information.

Discussion

This one is getting there, although I can find some things that can be improved. For example, there is nothing written about the 1999 look. Väsk 12:43, December 16, 2010 (UTC)

Rio 2016

 * Nominated by: Väsk 17:13, January 2, 2011 (UTC)
 * Motivation: Following the logo announcement, I've improved this article a lot. Probably enough to make it Good.

Discussion